The Great Smelly, Slobbery, Small-Tooth Dog
By Margaret Read MacDonald and Illustrated by Julie Paschkis
Publisher: August House
Genre: Children's Book/Folklore (32 pages)
Ages: 4-8 (pre-k -2nd grade)
Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
Book Blurb:
A rich man is rescued from harm by a smelly, slobbery dog. As a reward, he asks for the man's beautiful daughter. In this tale from England, Margaret Read MacDonald puts a new spin on the classic story, Beauty and the Beast.
I didn’t need the Blurb to tell me this was a retelling of Beauty and the Beast. A large dog saves a merchant and demands that the merchant's daughter come live with the dog.The girl goes with the dog of her own free will, because her father gave his word. From there, we get the nice kind girl having fun, playing with the dog in the day, and at night she is sad, feeling like a prisoner, until the dog hears her crying and took her home. It was only on the way home the girl started calling him names (Great Smelly, Slobbery, Small -Toothed Dog) and the dog whisked her back to his castle. At the end she learns the “lesson” and he becomes a prince.
This story is supposed to teach kindness since, in order for the girl to see her father again, she has to be kind to the dog. I guess this lesson would make sense if the daughter was known to be unkind to people, but in truth, like many Beauty and the Beast retellings, the girl is not unkind to anyone. And, only to the dog the closer she got to her home. I understand the value of being kind, but it was just out of left field. I am not looking for a whole character ark, but something more than “the girl, who had never shown any penchant for being a mean, unkind person now can not see her father because the person/dog keeping her locked in a castle will not let her see him, until she learns to be kind.” It just seems so random and not at all set up to be a lesson at all.
Beauty and the Beast also should teach children to look beyond a person's looks and find the person within. The part of the story is not even hinted at, and in this day and age, I think that is a very important lesson to teach. And I almost thought that this is where the book was going, showing us how the dog was befriending her, reading and playing etc.
I know this is a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, but the author could have put a little more into the lessons, tightened it up a bit. The author DOES have a way with words that would make this story fun for children to enjoy, it’s just I don’t like the weak message.
However, as much as I was not happy with the story, the art was STUNNING in an old tapestry look. The pictures flow with the movement and not one is a plain boring square setup.
In the end, I will say, this is not a book I would buy to keep, but maybe read to the kids, when we visit the library.
*I received a copy of this book from the publisher for an honest review*